Delicious fresh
made from scratch cookies.

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Photograph of chocolate chip cookies on white. www.sarahscookiejarnc.com

Our Best Selling Cookies

Deliciousness in Every Bite

Our Chocolate Chip Cookie is a top-selling preference. It’s a delicious twist on a classic favorite. If you have nut allergies or prefer an easy, traditional "chocolate lovers galore" cookie, we offer this option with chocolate chips only. Delicious and plentiful. Simplicity reigns supreme!

The signature Loaded Chocolate Chip Cookie is filled with rich chocolate chips, plump raisins, toasted coconut flakes, and crunchy walnuts, a delightful blend of tastes in every bite.

cookies on a plate with milk in the background. www.sarahscookiejarnc.com
Sarah's Cookie Jar Macadamia Nut Cookie

Macadamia Nut
& Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

Stack of oatmeal raisin cookies on a light wooden surface, with parchment paper between them and a few raisins scattered nearby.

Deliciousness in Every Bite

These golden-brown Macadamia Nut Cookies are baked to perfection, with a delicate balance of sweet, melt-in-your-mouth dough, and white chocolate chips. 

Our Oatmeal Raisin Cookies have slightly crispy edges with soft chewy centers, for the perfect texture. While raisins add bursts of sweetness throughout the cookie.

Here at Sarah’s Cookie Jar, we work with a small list of carefully chosen suppliers and source the freshest ingredients to deliver made-from-scratch cookies from our kitchen to your table. They’re simply delicious mouthfuls of goodness.

Order freshly baked cookies for your
next event

A stack of oatmeal cookies on a wooden cutting board with scattered oats around.

Office Events • Realtor Open Houses & Gifts • Parties • Weddings
• Baby Showers • And More

Your next event isn’t quite complete without the delicious cookies from Sarah’s Cookie Jar. Your guests will love the delightful treat that brings goodness in every bite and smiles to happy faces.

Sarah’s Cookie Jar Cookies speak for themselves.
And we will too…

  • Sarah’s Cookie Jar cookies are fresh, flavorful, and perfectly baked.

    “Sarah’s Cookie Jar cookies are fresh, flavorful, and perfectly baked. Great texture, great taste—definitely worth trying.”

    — Linda

  • They are delicious and perfect for those who have a sweet tooth.

    “These cookies are amazing! I would recommend the loaded chocolate chip. They are delicious and perfect for those who have a sweet tooth.”

    — The Skipper

  • A must-have for any event or even just as comfort food on a cozy weekend.

    “These cookies are so delicious, a must-have for any event or even just as comfort food on a cozy weekend.”

    — Angie

  • Mouth-watering, deliciousness with every single bite.

    “I love these cookies, all 4 flavors! With the first bite I thought — WOW, this is fabulous. Then another cookie awakened a subtle flavor of cinnamon! Every bite is a flavorful journey.

    Thank you all so much for bringing your cookies to the greater Wilmington, NC area.”

    —Bunkie

  • The wonderful taste is unlike any other cookie I’ve tried.

    “I’m a longtime fan of Sarah’s Cookie Jar Cookies. The wonderful taste is unlike any other cookie I’ve tried. And you can’t go wrong with any of the flavors, they’ll all leave you wondering when you’ll be able to enjoy them again!”

    — Jack

  • Cookies from Sarah’s Cookie Jar never disappoint.

    “I’ve ordered from Sarah’s Cookie Jar. I’ve tried the cookies on multiple occasions and they never disappoint. Maureen has made me a variety of different bags and I enjoy that I can get what I’d like and she will bag them accordingly. I’d continue to visit her again. She's friendly, and understanding, and I’m getting the best quality cookie that I order every time.”

    — Casey